Gula Melaka vs. Brown Sugar: Which One Is Better?

Index:

• Introduction

• What is Gula Melaka?

• How Is Gula Melaka Made?

• What is Brown Sugar?

• Types of Brown Sugar

• Gula Melaka vs. Brown Sugar: A Detailed Comparison

• Health Benefits: Which One is Healthier Gula Melaka or Brown Sugar?

• Which One Should You Use Between Gula Melaka and Brown Sugar?

• How to Substitute Gula Melaka for Brown Sugar

• FAQs About Gula Melaka and Brown Sugar

• Final Verdict: Which One Wins?

Introduction

When it comes to sweeteners, Gula Melaka (palm sugar) and brown sugar are widely used in desserts, drinks, and traditional delicacies. But which one is better?

While both offer a rich, caramel-like sweetness, they differ in flavor, nutritional value, and culinary uses. If you love Southeast Asian sweets like Sago Gula Melaka or Onde-Onde, you may already be familiar with Gula Melaka’s unique depth of flavor.

In this guide, we’ll compare Gula Melaka vs. Brown Sugar in terms of taste, health benefits, glycemic index, and best uses in cooking and baking. By the end, you’ll know exactly which sugar to use for your next recipe!

What is Gula Melaka?

Gula Melaka is a natural palm sugar made from the sap of coconut or date palm trees. It is a key ingredient in Southeast Asian desserts like Sago Gula Melaka and Onde-Onde, where its deep caramelized taste enhances their flavors.

How Is Gula Melaka Made?

1. The sap from coconut or palm trees is collected.

2. It is boiled until thick and caramelized.

3. The thickened syrup is poured into molds and left to harden into blocks.

   
   

Key Features:

✔ 100% natural, minimally processed

✔ Rich, smoky caramel taste

✔ Used in traditional Southeast Asian desserts like Sago Gula Melaka & Onde-Onde

What is Brown Sugar?

Brown sugar is refined white sugar mixed with molasses, giving it a darker color and richer taste. While it’s great for baking, it lacks the distinct smokiness of Gula Melaka, which makes dishes like Onde-Onde and Sago Gula Melaka special.

;

Types of Brown Sugar

• Light Brown Sugar – Milder caramel flavor, commonly used in cookies.

• Dark Brown Sugar – Higher molasses content, giving a deeper taste, great for sauces.

Key Features:

✔ Sweeter than Gula Melaka

✔ Easily available in supermarkets

✔ Common in Western baked goods

Gula Melaka vs. Brown Sugar: A Detailed Comparison

Feature	Gula Melaka (Palm Sugar)	Brown Sugar
Source	Coconut or palm tree sap	White sugar + molasses
Processing	Natural, minimally processed	Refined, processed
Taste	Rich, smoky, caramel-like	Sweet, mild molasses flavor
Glycemic Index (GI)	Lower (~35-40) – less blood sugar spike	Higher (~64-70) – raises blood sugar faster
Nutritional Value	Contains minerals like iron, zinc, and potassium	Mostly empty calories, few nutrients
Best Uses	Onde-Onde, Sago Gula Melaka, drinks, syrups	Baking, BBQ sauces, caramelized dishes
Availability	Mostly in Asian grocery stores	Common in supermarkets worldwide
Texture	Hard, requires grating or melting	Soft, granulated, easy to mix

Health Benefits: Which One is Healthier Gula Melaka or Brown Sugar?

1. Gula Melaka Has More Nutrients

Since Gula Melaka is unrefined, it retains more minerals like:

✔ Iron – Boosts blood health

✔ Zinc – Supports immunity

✔ Potassium – Helps maintain blood pressure

Brown sugar, on the other hand, is refined and contains minimal nutrients.

2. Gula Melaka Has a Lower Glycemic Index (GI)

• Gula Melaka GI: ~35-40 → Causes a slower rise in blood sugar

• Brown Sugar GI: ~64-70 → Spikes blood sugar faster

A lower GI means better blood sugar control, making Gula Melaka a better choice for people who love sweets like Sago Gula Melaka but want a healthier alternative.

3. Brown Sugar is More Versatile in Baking

• Brown sugar blends better into baked goods like cookies and cakes.

• Gula Melaka needs grating or melting before use, which requires extra effort.

Which One Should You Use Between Gula Melaka and Brown Sugar?

Choose Gula Melaka If You Want:

✔ A healthier, unrefined sugar with minerals

✔ A lower glycemic index (better for blood sugar control)

✔ A deep, caramel-like smoky flavor in Asian desserts like Sago Gula Melaka & Onde-Onde

Choose Brown Sugar If You Want:

✔ A convenient, easy-to-use sweetener for baking

✔ A sugar that blends well in doughs and sauces

✔ A classic Western-style sweet flavor for cookies, cakes, and caramel sauces

How to Substitute Gula Melaka for Brown Sugar

Since Gula Melaka is less sweet than brown sugar, use this ratio:

🔥 1 cup brown sugar = ¾ cup grated Gula Melaka + 1 tbsp water

This helps dissolve the Gula Melaka and balances the sweetness, making it perfect for traditional dishes like Sago Gula Melaka syrup or Onde-Onde filling.

👉 Tip: Melt Gula Melaka with water to make a syrup, then use it in recipes.

FAQs About Gula Melaka and Brown Sugar

1. Is Gula Melaka the same as brown sugar?

No, Gula Melaka is natural palm sugar, while brown sugar is white sugar mixed with molasses. Gula Melaka has more minerals and a lower glycemic index.

2. Can I use Gula Melaka instead of brown sugar in baking?

Yes, but you need to grate or melt Gula Melaka first. It works well in moist cakes, cookies, and caramel sauces.

3. Which is healthier: Gula Melaka or brown sugar?

Gula Melaka is healthier because it’s unrefined, has more minerals, and has a lower glycemic index than brown sugar.

4. Where can I buy Gula Melaka?

You can find Gula Melaka in Asian grocery stores, specialty markets, or online retailers like Amazon.

5. What does Gula Melaka taste like?

It has a rich caramel, toffee, and smoky flavor, making it perfect for traditional treats like Sago Gula Melaka and Onde-Onde.

Final Verdict: Which One Wins?

For health-conscious individuals and Southeast Asian cuisine lovers → Gula Melaka is the better choice.For convenience and Western-style baking → Brown sugar is the best option.

If possible, try both and experiment with different flavors in your cooking! 🍯🔥